This Money Advice Is 100% Wrong

By Sallie Krawcheck

The latte conversation is back. Yes, even during a pandemic. When I looked yesterday, I saw nearly 200K comments on Matt Bellassai’s Starbucks tweet from a couple of weeks ago:

A screenshot of a tweet that says, “been making coffee at home instead of getting starbucks for two months which according to economists should’ve made me a billionaire by now so what is happening.”

When we shared it on our Instagram, the community lit up. (My favorite response was by @msyoungprofessional, who perfectly skewered this advice by commenting: “I saved billions by making coffee at home and also by being a billionaire before I started making coffee at home. It’s so easy!”)

ICYMI: “Skip the latte” is bad financial advice.

The basic idea is this: “You’re throwing money down the drain by buying coffee in the store.” “If you invest that latte money in the stock market instead, you can become a millionaire.” I’ve heard it a million times — in good years and in bad.

Here’s better advice:

Are you kidding? When we’re on the other side of this pandemic, I’m dancing to the coffee shop every morning on my way to work, to treat myself to some delicious, warm, milky, frothy latte.

I’ll do so knowing that I’ve done the math. In order to become a latte millionaire, I would have to earn stock market returns that is literally multiples of what the typical individual investor has earned over the past 20 years.

I firmly believe that whenever you can, you should treat yourself to the little things that make you happy, without guilt. At the same time, you can get the big things — including the math on financial decisions — right. There’s been a lot of bad math out there lately … and not all of it’s about coffee.

Betting on individual stocks during the pandemic (or anytime) is bad advice.

A survey of just a few recent headlines:

The gist of each of them is that the economic downturn is a fantastic (even “once-in-a-lifetime”) opportunity for you to “time the market” — aka guess when individual stocks might go up or down in price and buy or sell them accordingly.

Here’s better advice: Stick with investing regularly and for the long term.

The problem is that “timing the market” approach is a loser. Of course, you can make some occasional great trades (and give yourself some great Zoom cocktail party chatter), but trading in and out of the market just doesn't consistently work.

It doesn’t work for regular people with investments. And it doesn’t even work for professional investors who get paid to do it: in fact, less than 1% of professional mutual fund managers who used the strategy were successful. Even Warren Buffett — literally the greatest investor of our time — says nobody can time the market; he doesn't even try.

Instead, we typically recommend investing for the long term, regularly, a little at a time, regardless of whether the stock market is up or down. It’s called dollar-cost averaging.

Here’s some math on that: If you had stayed invested in the stock market for the past 20 years and not touched it, your money would have tripled. But if you had traded in and out and had missed out on just the ten best stock market days over that period — that’s right, just ten days — your returns would have been just half of that.

“Build up an emergency fund before paying off your credit card” is bad advice.

This one hurts a little. I have long been a Suze Orman fan. I love what she has built. I love that she pulled herself up by her bootstraps to do it. I love that she managed to do it in an industry that has had few successful women. I LOVE that she tells people to “stand in their truth” of their own financial circumstances. (I might have used different words, but the underlying concept of rejecting the shame around money and living within your means is a great one.)

But when I read the advice she gave in a recent New York Times article … the math just doesn’t work out. Reversing her previous advice, Suze is now telling people to build an emergency fund even if that means leaving your credit card debt outstanding and paying just the minimum that’s due.

Better advice: Save a small cushion of cash, then dive in and pay off that high-interest debt — and then finish your emergency fund.

At Ellevest, we’re all for an emergency fund: that three to six months’ (or more!) of take-home pay in a FDIC-insured bank account (or NCUA-insured credit union account), just in case something happens and you need a buffer. And we also know that having even a small safety net in cash — especially in times like these — can help us sleep at night, knowing we can cover any big sudden expense while we work on getting rid of debt.

But your high-interest rate debt, like credit cards, is expensive. Really expensive. Credit card interest rates average 16% right now. Meanwhile, that emergency fund will earn you just about 0%.

How much can that cost you?

Let’s do a little math experiment: Say you have a credit card balance of $6,200 (the national average) and an extra $200 per month. You can use that $200 to pay down the credit card, or you could use it to build an emergency fund, while just paying the minimum due on the credit card.*

After six months, keeping that credit card debt outstanding (while building the emergency fund) would have cost you $483 in interest. Oof. That’s almost $500 down the drain.

Now, assume you have an actual emergency six months in, which costs you $1,000. By now, you have a little more than that saved in your emergency fund, so you pay for the emergency out of the emergency fund. Call that Scenario A. If you don’t — well, you run the credit card back up. Call that Scenario B.

Here’s the thing: By the end of one year, Scenario A will have cost you $101 more than Scenario B. That’s because the interest on your credit card balance compounds — meaning you have to pay interest on your interest. The longer you take to pay your balance off, the more it will cost you overall.

And here’s the other thing: It may take you quite a while to build up three or more months’ worth of take-home pay. If just six months of paying only the minimums on your credit cards while you prioritize your emergency fund costs you $483 in interest, imagine how much extra you’d pay if you just kept paying the minimums indefinitely.

(Hey, you may say, but what if I have an emergency and at the exact time I do, the bank cancels my credit card?? Well, the chances of those two things happening simultaneously are vanishingly small. And so you are paying for a very expensive “insurance policy” for a highly unlikely event. Lightning strike stuff.)

In each of these cases, spending too much time on your emergency fund before you pay off your credit card balance simply means that you’re transferring a lot of your hard-earned money directly to the credit card company in the meantime.

That said, having a little bit stashed away to pay bills can offer a safe backstop while you do it, even if it’s just peace of mind. (That’s why Suze’s emergency-fund-before-all advice feels “right.“) That’s why we now recommend starting with that one-month mini-fund — to handle immediate, unexpected bills that come up — before moving onto your biggest, baddest debt.

“Bitcoin is skyrocketing — don’t miss this opportunity!” is bad advice.

Since the pandemic began, I’ve seen advice to “load up” on Bitcoin as a hedge against inflation, people calling it “digital gold” that’s gone way up as the rest of the economy tumbled, and other people calling it “ready for a crash.” A couple of weeks ago, Bitcoin went through a process called halvening** that spawned some excitement on Twitter and least one “spiritual reflection.” OK. (Even Suze commented on it and that “many people think that it probably will” go up. Not OK.)

Ellevest’s Bitcoin advice: No. Just no.

Unlike stocks and bonds and other investments at Ellevest, Bitcoin has no fundamental underpinning. It’s not like a “real currency” that is tied to a country’s underlying real economy. It goes up or down based on pure sentiment.

The only advice “experts” should be giving is that you’re only allowed to buy Bitcoin with the money you would have gambled on that trip to Vegas that’s now indefinitely postponed — assuming you have all your credit card debts paid off, your emergency fund built up, and you’re investing wisely for the future, that is.

The bottom line is this: As everyone — especially women — loses financial ground during this pandemic, it’s really important that we all have reliable, achievable, and mathematically grounded financial advice. We’ve got you covered there.

Sallie Krawcheck Signature


Results calculated by Ellevest. We assume that the credit card has a 16% APR and beginning minimum required payment of $145, which this person treats as fixed throughout the payoff period. We also assume that the $200 available for either saving or making extra payments exists above and beyond that payment. We assume that the emergency happens at the end of month six. Finally, we assume that any money saved is not earning interest.

Gonna be honest. I have no idea what this is.

© 2020 Ellevest, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

* Results calculated by Ellevest. We assume that the credit card has a 16% APR and beginning minimum required payment of $145, which this person treats as fixed throughout the payoff period. We also assume that the $200 available for either saving or making extra payments exists above and beyond that payment. We assume that the emergency happens at the end of month six. Finally, we assume that any money saved is not earning interest.

Information was obtained from third-party sources, which we believe to be reliable but not guaranteed for accuracy or completeness.

All opinions and views expressed by Ellevest are current as of the date of this writing, for informational purposes only, and do not constitute or imply an endorsement of any third party’s products or services.

The information provided should not be relied upon as investment advice or recommendations, does not constitute a solicitation to buy or sell securities and should not be considered specific legal, investment or tax advice.

Forecasts or projections of investment outcomes are estimates only, based upon numerous assumptions about future capital markets returns and economic factors. As estimates, they are imprecise and hypothetical in nature, do not reflect actual investment results, and are not guarantees of future results.

The information provided does not take into account the specific objectives, financial situation or particular needs of any specific person.

Investing entails risk, including the possible loss of principal, and there is no assurance that the investment will provide positive performance over any period of time.

Banking products and services are provided by Coastal Community Bank (“Coastal”), member FDIC, pursuant to license by Mastercard International. Your Ellevest Save and Spend Account deposits will be insured to the regulatory limits by the FDIC.

Together, the Ellevest Save and Spend accounts are FDIC-insured up to $250,000 per depositor through Coastal Community Bank, Member FDIC.

A newsletter you’ll love

Get all the news, advice, and must-know info on women, money, and career.

Sallie Krawcheck

Sallie Krawcheck is the Founder & CEO of Ellevest.